|
|
Post by I Voted For Kodos on Oct 30, 2015 21:52:14 GMT
These ratings are based on the views of people who were at the game. If you watched it on TV at the Mem then feel free to give your opinions but state how you watched it.
Nicholls
J. Clarke
Lockyer
McChrystal
Brown
Bodin
Mansell
Sinclair
Gosling
Easter
Harrison
Sub: Taylor
Crowd
Ref
Cambridge
|
|
|
|
Post by Nortongashead on Oct 30, 2015 22:49:12 GMT
Nicholls 6 not a lot to do. My only question is whether he could have claimed cross for their goal.
J. Clarke 6 grew into the game, solid.
Lockyer 6 won his fair share of challenges.
McChrystal 7 good performance and battling performance
Brown 6 solid and consistent.
Bodin 5 quiet game but always looked a threat.
Mansell 6 battled well not commanding but did a job
Sinclair 6 usual running a little less quality tonight
Gosling 5 some good touches in and out of the game
Easter 5 tried but not his night
Harrison 7 scored and hit bar. Battled well.
Sub: Taylor 9 MOTM changed the game with his ability. Assist and goal.
Crowd 7
Ref 5
Cambridge 4 poor side that offered little in terms of entertainment.
Watched at the Abbey Stadium, Cambridge! |
|
|
|
Post by Gas Go Marching In on Oct 30, 2015 22:58:36 GMT
Nicholls 6 Didn't have much to do. Becoming more and more evident with every game that he needs to come off his line more. Distribution is great though.
J. Clarke 5.5 Would have preferred Leadbitter personally and should have been tighter for their goal.
Lockyer 6 Average.
McChrystal 6 Average.
Brown 6 Average
Bodin 5 Not one of his better games.
Mansell 6 Average.
Sinclair 6.5 Industrious performance albeit lacking quality
Gosling 7 Bright game. Some good first touch passes.
Easter 5 Quiet, disappointing.
Harrison 7 Won quite a bit in the air and a typical poacher's goal that we've missed at times.
Sub: Taylor 9. Well what can I say? Absolute revelation. Pretty much won the game for us single handedly. Harrison thought he proved the doubters wrong but Taylor did even more so. MOTM by a country mile.
Crowd 8 First half couldn't hear f**k all on the TV so moved downstairs and it was a great atmosphere both on the tv and at the ground. A proud night to be a gashead.
Ref 5 Didn't feel like he gave a lot our way and another inconsistent ref which we've become accustomed to sadly.
Cambridge 5. Took their goal well. Disappointed with them given their budget.
Watched on TV.
|
|
|
|
Post by Gas Go Marching In on Oct 30, 2015 22:59:52 GMT
Nicholls 6 not a lot to do. My only question is whether he could have claimed cross for their goal. J. Clarke 6 grew into the game, solid. Lockyer 6 won his fair share of challenges. McChrystal 7 good performance and battling performance Brown 6 solid and consistent. Bodin 5 quiet game but always looked a threat. Mansell 6 battled well not commanding but did a job Sinclair 6 usual running a little less quality tonight Gosling 5 some good touches in and out of the game Easter 5 tried but not his night Harrison 7 scored and hit bar. Battled well. Sub: Taylor 9 MOTM changed the game with his ability. Assist and goal. Crowd 7 Ref 5 Cambridge 4 poor side that offered little in terms of entertainment. TV or at game? |
|
|
|
Post by joebananas67 on Oct 31, 2015 0:02:13 GMT
Nicholls 6 not a lot to do. My only question is whether he could have claimed cross for their goal. J. Clarke 6 grew into the game, solid. Lockyer 6 won his fair share of challenges. McChrystal 7 good performance and battling performance Brown 6 solid and consistent. Bodin 5 quiet game but always looked a threat. Mansell 6 battled well not commanding but did a job Sinclair 6 usual running a little less quality tonight Gosling 5 some good touches in and out of the game Easter 5 tried but not his night Harrison 7 scored and hit bar. Battled well. Sub: Taylor 9 MOTM changed the game with his ability. Assist and goal. Crowd 7 Ref 5 Cambridge 4 poor side that offered little in terms of entertainment. TV or at game? were you at the game GGMI?
Past your bedtime surely
|
|
|
|
Post by Gas Go Marching In on Oct 31, 2015 0:03:51 GMT
were you at the game GGMI?
Past your bedtime surely
Read above and you will see the answer to that one. Please don't start on here as well. It's getting embarrassing and annoying other forum users. |
|
|
|
Post by Russgas on Oct 31, 2015 0:12:57 GMT
Nicholls 6 Was not troubled a great deal. Handling much better.
J. Clarke 6 Steady game.
Lockyer 6.5. solid as usual.
McChrystal 6.5 Dependable.
Brown 6 Got forward when he could.
Bodin 5 Average
Mansell 6 Battled well.
Sinclair 6.5 Usual workmanlike performance.
Gosling 6.5 Drifted in & out of the game. Better second half.
Easter 4 To slow,well below par.
Harrison 7 Good performance.
Sub: Taylor 8 MOM. His best game so far.Took his goal so well.
Crowd 7
Ref 5
Cambridge 4 Poor team. Got what they deserved....Nowt.
Watched on the Screen in the East stand.
|
|
|
|
Post by joebananas67 on Oct 31, 2015 0:55:37 GMT
were you at the game GGMI?
Past your bedtime surely
Read above and you will see the answer to that one. Please don't start on here as well. It's getting embarrassing and annoying other forum users. Oh I see.
I didn't think it was important to read a post before commenting on it.
So were you at the game tonight.
Oh obviously not otherwise you wouldn't have hijacked my thread earlier by suggesting DC bring Lines on.
Anyway. Not ruining the thread, its' just banter isn't it at the end of the day.
Get used to it. There is not lot more to come. Night night
|
|
|
|
Post by joebananas67 on Oct 31, 2015 1:35:37 GMT
Nicholls 6 - bit indecisive on occasions but that could be down to last weekend and his error at Morecambe. Keen to distribute early and handling sound. No chance with goal J. Clarke 7.5 - solid performance but caught out of position for first goal cross Lockyer 8 - solid and dependable McChrystal 7.5 - first half was given a torrid time by Corr but won everything in second half Brown 7 - one complete breakdown of communication in first half with Mac but very solid defensively thereafter Bodin 7.5 - the only bright spark of the first half and very willing to put a foot in and head in when needed. Mansell 7.5 - far better second half Sinclair 8.5 MOM - brilliant performance going forward and in defence. Broke things up, spread the ball wide easily Gosling - 7.5 like Mansell far better second half but always looking to cut inside. We know he can hit a ball from distance so hit it Easter - 7 - some nice hold play but we really never got going first half. Correctly subbed Harrison - 8.5 Almost MOM as for me this was his best all round performance in a Rovers shirt for some time. Should have scored early in second half. Scored the equaliser and general forward play in the second half will give the Cambridge defenders nightmares for weeks Sub: Taylor 7 - made an instant impact for the equaliser. Confident finish for the winner but should have hade two more. Feigning injury has never been a favourite of mine but his amateur dramatics for the ankle injury cost him a point (just a personal gripe as I hate the opposition doing it so being consistent) Crowd 6large in number quiet in voice. FDantastic turnout on a Friday evening Ref 6 - second half very good and willing to allow the physical challenges at this level Cambridge 4- faded badly and we stood off them too far in the first half 45mins |
|
|
|
Post by smudge1 on Oct 31, 2015 8:51:34 GMT
Nicholls - 6 looked nervy
Clarke - 7 We miss him when he is not playing
Lockyer - 8.5 Top drawer
McChrystal - 8.5 Better with him in the team
Brown - 7 Consistent
Bodin - 6.5 Quiet game would like to see him play as a striker sometimes
Mansell - 6.5 steady
Sinclair - 9 Mom he was everywhere
Gosling - 7 Patchy in places
Easter - 6 Needs to feed off a big man
Harrison - 8 A handful, but not quite as good as DC thought
Taylor - 8.5 Changed the game
Crowd - 8 could hear them on the live stream
Ref - 6 average but didn't flash the cards around
Cambridge - played the ball around nicely but too much reliance on Corrs.
Watched the live stream
|
|
|
|
Post by radman on Oct 31, 2015 9:18:19 GMT
NICHOLLS 6 OK
J CLARKE 7.5 SOLID GOT SOME GOOD CROSS IN
LOCKYER 7.5 GOOD GAME
MCCHRYSTAL 7.5 LEFT HIS MAN UN MARKED FOR THERE GOAL
BROWN 7 OK
BODIN 6.5 OK BIT QUIET
MANSELL 6.5 BETTER SECOND HALF
SINCLAIR 8 PLAYED WELL
GOSLING 7 BETTER SECOND HALF
EASTER 6 NEVER GOT GOING
HARRISON 8 FOR ME ONE OF HIS BEST GAMES
TAYLOR 8 GREAT GOAL PLAYED WELL
PARKING CRAP AT THE GROUND . FOR ME THE STRONGEST BACK FOR WE GOT MUCH BETTER THAN LAST WEEK
DC GOOD CHANGE FOR THE BACK FOUR, SEAM HE SWAPS THE TEAM TO SUIT THE GAME
|
|
|
|
Post by gwengers on Oct 31, 2015 17:49:55 GMT
Watched the game in person.
Nicholls 6.5
J. Clarke 6
Lockyer 7.5
McChrystal 6
Brown 6.5
Bodin 6.5
Mansell 6
Sinclair 7
Gosling 7
Easter 5
Harrison 7
Sub: Taylor 9
Crowd 6
Ref 6
Cambridge 5
|
|
|
|
Post by stevek192 on Oct 31, 2015 19:40:46 GMT
Nicholls 7
J Clarke 6.5
McCrystal 7.5 MOM
Lockyer 7
Brown 7
Bodin 6
Mansell 6
Sinclair 7
Gosling 6.5
Harrison 7
Easter 5
Substitutions Taylor 7.5
Crowd 9 What a turnout again when you consider the distance, the fact it was a night game and probably even more important that we lost last week 4-1. The fact it was beamed back to the Mem makes it even more amazing.
Referee 6
Cambridge 6
|
|
|
|
Post by radman on Nov 1, 2015 9:49:20 GMT
Just watched the goal back what was the two c/h playing at ,both looking the wrong way they had so much time to see the cross ,and the man standing there un marked ,really bad goal to give away DC need to work on them both about that .no talking I bet .
|
|
|
|
Post by I Voted For Kodos on Nov 2, 2015 21:56:11 GMT
Sorry all, I somehow forgot about the Ratings thread until this evening. Anyway here are the final ratings: Matty Taylor was the Man of the Match, the first substitute to do so this season. Last season only Blissett (Welling home) and Harrison (Halifax away) won MotM as a sub. Taylor was reliant on the 4th official to do so. My criteria is a player has to be on the pitch 30 minutes to qualify. Thanks to the 4 minutes of injury time, Taylor was on the pitch for 32 minutes. Maybe that's why he was rolling on the floor holding his ankle.  These are the ratings for those at the game, those who watched on TV are in brackets. They are broadly similar. Those at the game gave an average staring XI rating of 6.7, those on TV a 6.6. Interestingly though, those that watched on TV gave a higher score for the crowd. Nicholls 6.4 (6.0)
J. Clarke 6.5 (6.5)Lockyer 7.1 (7.1)McChrystal 7.0 (7.1)Brown 6.6 (6.5)Bodin 5.3 (6.3)Mansell 6.4 (6.3)Sinclair 7.0 (7.5)Gosling 6.5 (6.9)Harrison 7.4 (7.5)Easter 5.5 (5.3)Sub: Taylor 8.1 (8.4)Crowd 7.0 (7.7)Ref 5.8 (5.3)Cambridge 4.8 (4.5) |
|
