|
|
Post by I Voted For Kodos on Oct 2, 2021 16:07:16 GMT
Belshaw
Kilgour
Taylor
Harries
Anderson
Coutts
Whelan
Brown
Evans
Finley
Pitman
Subs: Saunders
Collins
Hoole
Westbrooke
Ref
Swindon
|
|
|
|
Post by Russgas on Oct 2, 2021 16:12:49 GMT
Belshaw 7
Kilgour 4
Taylor 5
Harries 5
Anderson 6
Coutts 3
Whelan 3
Brown 6
Evans 5
Finley 6
Pitman 3
Subs: Saunders 4
Collins 4
Hoole 5
Westbrooke nole
Ref 3
Swindon 6
|
|
|
|
Post by meadgas on Oct 2, 2021 16:50:40 GMT
Belshaw 6 Kilgour 4 Taylor 6 Harries 5 Anderson 5 Coutts 3 Whelan 3 Brown 6 Evans 4 Finley 6,5 Pitman 3 Subs: Saunders 4 Collins 3 Hoole 5 Westbrooke nole Ref 3 Swindon 6 Barton 1 and a train ticket back to Liverpool |
|
|
|
Post by smudge1 on Oct 2, 2021 16:57:30 GMT
Belshaw 7
Kilgour 5
Taylor 5
Harries 4
Coutts 4
Whelan 4
Evans 5
Anderson 5
Brown 5
Finley 6
Pitman 3
Saunders 4
Collins 4
Westbrooke 4
Hoole 6
Ref 5
Swindon 8
Barton out!
|
|
|
|
Post by o2o2bo2ba on Oct 2, 2021 17:27:12 GMT
Belshaw 7.5 m o m everyone is allowed a mistake, but he stayed on his line a lot...
Kilgour 3 unfortunately up until his sending off he was doing ok, but why make a rash challenge when matey isn't going anywhere that gets you booked for no valid reason? That was nail in coffin and he let the team down.
Taylor 7 almost m o m but concussion conspired to force him out the game today and probably next week too.
Harries 7 great blocking and tackles but not so good in distribution.
Anderson 6.5 took his chance well, but gave away easy possession that led to first goal.
Coutts 4 gave ball away, played too deep, cr@p captain.... however, his pass to Evans was almost as visionary as Evan's pass to Anderson for the goal. Such a disappointing campaign so far.
Whelan 4 don't understand his inclusion. Subbed way too late. Gave ball away, too deep..
Brown 5 hard working unit, but it just didn't work as his tackling/headers weren't won and wasn't quick enough to win 2nd ball. Set pieces too close to Keeper.
Evans 3 apart from through ball to Anderson, what did he do?
Finley 4 danced around a bit, can't think of any action he set up or contributed to..
Pitman 3 no service to him tbf, but BARTON got it wrong with his inclusion.
Subs: Saunders 5 worked hard again but no impact.
Collins 4 as Saunders.
Hoole 7.5 great inclusion and even had header on target albeit tame effort.
Westbrooke 2 why?
Ref 1 honestly baffling decisions, inconsistent, potentially cost us the match as I honestly couldn't see a handball.. happy to be proved wrong.
Swindon 8.5 the best team I've seen so far. Credit for their result and performance and playing Inn the right way..... congrats BG definitely deserved it.
You got it so wrong, JAB that it's taking the p!ss when you bring on Westbrook for Pitman when you need a goal.... what's wrong with Spence whom is best finisher in the club and wants to play for us instead of his country?
Why play at home with 8 at the back?
Why play with no attacking football??
BARTON OUT!
|
|
|
|
Post by lisbongas on Oct 2, 2021 17:45:35 GMT
Belshaw Played well before giving the last goal away. Needs to recognise the quality of our players when going short as often we put needless pressure on ourselves 6 Kilgour stupid tackle that deserved a yellow card lacks quality and a cool head,penalty may of been harsh but overall not good enough 4 Taylor Solid game motm but had little competition 7 Harries too often has moments when he frustratingly seems to lose concentration and allows opposition a chance.6 Anderson great goal but his mistake gave the ballaway that led to the goal. Part of a poor midfield 5 Coutts a really poor performance he should be dropped 3 Whelan old slow and part of the central pairing that were outplayed and out fought. 4 Brown positive first half but inflence faded in second half 5 Evans fantastic pass that set up our goal, but another who did little after we scored 5 Finley neat touches but created nothing 5 Pitman a liability we must find better 4 Subs Saunders ran around but ineffectual 4 Collins ditto 4 Hoole nole Westbooke nole Ref not the reason we lost but did us no favours 6 Swindon outplayed us in all positions Garner will be enjoying champers tonight 7 Crowd hard to get up when served dross |
|
Biggsy
Reserve Team
Posts: 352
|
Post by Biggsy on Oct 2, 2021 19:13:24 GMT
Belshaw 6.5 kept the score down, one bad mistake but a couple of good saves outweighed the one bad one. Kilgour 5 part of a poor defence that was always going to concede. Taylor 7 m.o.m battled gamely until injury. Harries 5 as Alfie Anderson 6.5 a well taken goal, good going forward, unconvincing when defending Coutts 4 not impressed, Mehew and Hargreaves should be recalled asap and given a chance,they could do no worse. Whelan 5 neat and tidy but doesnt affect the game much Brown 5.5 some impressive headers that weren't capitalised on Evans 5 one sublime pass but this is league two,its not enough. Finley 6 doesnt play well when Coutts is in the team Pitman 5 an ageing unfit guy,past his best playing as a lone striker.you couldn't make it up !! Subs: Saunders 5 plenty of energy Collins 4 made no impact Hoole 6 a good cameo Westbrooke 4 waste of time ,why not Spence? Ref 4 league two ref, pretty dire. Swindon 7 better than us in every department I'm still waiting for the team Barton said we would be proud of, because this shower of sh*t certainly isn't it. |
|
|
|
Post by seanclevedongas on Oct 2, 2021 19:33:30 GMT
Belshaw 7 kept the score down
Kilgour 4 I think he was unlucky with the penalty and dismissal
Taylor 5 Will be a big miss next week
Harries 5
Anderson 5 great goal
Coutts 3
Whelan 3
Brown 3
Evans 5
Finley 5
Pitman 0 we may as well start the game with 10 men
Subs: Saunders 3
Collins 3
Hoole 7
Westbrooke nole
Ref 3
Swindon 8
|
|
|
|
Post by gasssss95 on Oct 2, 2021 20:43:55 GMT
Belshaw 6 only marked down for the one mistake
Kilgour 4 rash
Taylor 6 our best defender
Harries 6 fine but got turned a few times
Anderson 5 we’ll taken goal, did nothing else
Coutts 4 not enough influence
Whelan 4.5 only slightly better than captain
Brown 5.5 faded
Evans 6.5 looked our only threat
Finley 6 a few nice turns and runs
Pitman 2 diabolical
Subs: Saunders 5 huffed and puffed
Collins 3 added nothing
Hoole 6 put himself about
Westbrooke na
Ref 5 hmmm
Swindon 7 loads better than us
|
|
|
|
Post by stevek192 on Oct 2, 2021 20:58:53 GMT
Belshaw 6.5
Kilgour 4
Taylor 7
Harries 6
Anderson 5.5
Coutts 3
Whelan 3,5
Brown 5.5
Evans 5
Finley 6
Pitman 3
Subs: Saunders 5
Collins 3
Hoole 6
Westbrooke nole but that was too long.
Ref 3
Swindon 8.5
|
|
|
|
Post by eastville1966 on Oct 2, 2021 21:10:01 GMT
Belshaw 7
Kilgour 4
Taylor 5
Harries 4
Anderson 5
Coutts 4
Whelan 4
Brown 5
Evans 4
Finley 5
Pitman 3
Subs: Saunders 4
Collins 4
Hoole 5
Westbrooke 3
Ref 3
Swindon 7
|
|
|
|
Post by Sir Trevor on Oct 3, 2021 16:03:10 GMT
Belshaw 5.5
Kilgour 4
Taylor 5
Harries 5
Anderson 4.5
Coutts 4
Whelan 3.5
Brown 5.5
Evans 4.5
Finley 5.5
Pitman 3
Subs: Saunders 5
Collins 3.5
Hoole 6
Westbrooke 4
Ref 4
Swindon 7
|
|
|
|
Post by I Voted For Kodos on Oct 4, 2021 9:47:42 GMT
Results in and James Belshaw was Man of the Match with a score of 6.54.
In the last 5 league games, Belshaw and Taylor have racked up 4 MotMs and 5 Runner-up spots between them. This is the most dominant 5-game run by a pair of players since Ollie Clarke and Jack Bonham from Shrewsbury (A) to Bradford (A) on 2018/19 (5 MotM and 4 RU)
Swindon's rating of 7.3 was the highest rating for an opposition at the Mem since Peterborough (7.9) in the 10th game of last season.
The starting XI average was 4.81.
10 games in, I'll take a look at the season averages shortly.
Belshaw 6.5
Kilgour 4.1
Taylor 5.9
Harries 5.2
Anderson 5.4
Coutts 3.6
Whelan 3.8
Brown 5.2
Evans 4.8
Finley 5.6
Pitman 2.8
Subs: Saunders 4.5
Collins 3.8
Hoole 5.8
Westbrooke 4.1
Ref 3.9
Swindon 7.3
|
|
